Variance reporting: What is it + how to read write a variance report

It is not always possible to predict with certainty the date activities will take place and often these are beyond the control of a budget holder. In regards to financial close, a financial software automation solution can help achieve efficiency. Download our data sheet to learn how you can run your processes up to 100x faster and with 98% fewer errors. Download our data sheet to learn how to automate your reconciliations for increased accuracy, speed and control. Variance analysis becomes an integral part of an organisation’s information system.

  1. The variances usually are displayed in the form of floating bar charts—also known as walk, bridge, or waterfall charts.
  2. The difference between budgeted and actual labor used in a given period.
  3. Unfavorable variances mean your prediction is better than the actual outcome.
  4. When preparing the budget for our direct labour, we take our predicted sales and multiply this by the budgeted labour hours used per unit and the rate of pay for our labour / employees.

In fact, sometimes this whole process is called standard costing (the “costing” part of that term reflects how much variance analysis attention focuses on costs). I have to control for other causes first, and only look at how much variance is realistically due to a particular cause. That involves subdividing variances based on their cause, and it’s a prerequisite for actionable information. Managers only invest time and money in variance analysis because it will help them improve future-period profit.

Volume Variance

(c) Measurement deviation arises as a result of error in measuring the actual outcome. (a) Implementation deviation results from a human or mechanical failure to achieve an attainable income. To tackle this problem, organizations should develop robust data management practices. Data validation procedures should be in place to minimize the chances of errors infiltrating the analysis. Additionally, continuous data updates are crucial to keep up with any changes that may occur. The other main cause of variances is that the planned activity changes.

Stay up to date on the latest accounting tips and training

This is essentially determining the differences between what was expected and what happened in reality. This could be calculated in units, percentage or monetary value depending on the variables being measured. The variances may be favorable (better than expected) or unfavorable (worse than expected). Basic variances can be calculated for sales, material, labour,variable overheads and fixed overheads. Variable overhead variances mean something a little different than direct materials and direct labor variances.

A flexible budget allows for changes and updates to be made when assumptions used to devise the budget are altered. A static budget remains the same, however, even if the assumptions change. The flexible budget thus allows for greater adaptability to changing circumstances and should result in less of a budget variance, both positive and negative. Because variance analysis is such a powerful risk management tool, there is a strong case for including it in the finance portion of any MBA curriculum. Yet fewer than half of finance professors believe they should be teaching this subject; they view it as a topic more typically taught in accounting classes.

These T-accounts are debited or credited as costs are applied to WIP. Variances are usually expressed as absolute values followed by either “unfavorable” or “favorable,” based on whether the variance pushes firm profit lower or higher, respectively. The square root of the variance is the standard deviation (SD or σ), which helps determine the consistency of an investment’s returns over a period of time. Because universities mostly fail to teach this important topic, corporate educators have been left to fill the learning gap. Many global organizations, in fact, make variance analysis a key subject in their development programs for entry-level financial professionals. Executives who understand variances will improve their risk management, make better decisions, and be more likely to meet commitments.

This is also sometimes called an “efficiency” variance or a “usage” variance. An unfavorable direct materials quantity variance suggests the firm is being inefficient with its direct materials on the production floor. With a little investigative effort, the firm can figure out an action to improve this variance. One of the rules of thumb for variance analysis is that WIP receives all costs at standard.

The Role of Standards in Variance Analysis

Favorable variances mean you’re doing better in an area of your business than anticipated. Unfavorable variances mean your prediction is better than the actual outcome. Variance analysis also aids in reasons for variances making informed decisions about future strategies for sustainability. It can provide actionable insights into which practices are having the most positive sustainable impact and are cost-effective.

(The asterisk reflects how the flexible budget’s “budgeted quantity” is how much input would have been budgeted at the actual number of units produced). Product costs, such as direct labor and direct materials are among the most important of these cost variances. So multi-product firms often break down sales volume variance into sales mix and yield variances. I cover this later in Section 7.8 because mix and yield variances are relevant to cost variances as well. Variance analysis can be summarized as an analysis of the difference between planned and actual numbers.

Identifying the causes of variances

‍This is the difference between how many hours were worked versus what was budgeted for the work. It is calculated by standard overhead rate x (actual hours – standard hours). Take the actual price paid for a direct job, subtract the standard cost and multiply by the number of units used (wages). See, if you’re splitting the quantity variance into mix and yield variances, then there are multiple inputs that can be substituted for each other. Yield variance then is just the traditional quantity variance (i.e. how many finished goods units come from the given input units) adapted to this idea of substitutable inputs.

The sooner an unfavorable variance is detected, the sooner attention can be directed towards fixing any problems. This is when your results outperform estimates (overall or in one aspect of the budget). Positive variances result from changes such as better-than-expected prices on materials, higher sales, lower overhead costs, or more efficient production. If you find that the actual cost is more than the planned budget (unfavorable variance), you can look deeper into the elements causing this overspending. Maybe the logistics costs were higher than planned, or perhaps an unexpected expense cropped up partway through the project. Either way, understanding and addressing these disparities can help ensure better financial management of CSR initiatives in the future.

So the allocation of fixed overhead matches a variable cost pattern in that it varies with production volume. Thus the cost driver-allocated of fixed overhead figure is more fictitious than the static budget figure. That static budget knows better than to treat fixed overhead as if it were a variable cost. The logic from previous cost variances about how to judge favorability as we move from the more hypothetical number (i.e. more rightward) to the more actual number (i.e. more leftward) continues to work.

Significance of a Budget Variance

A static budget (column F) and a flexible budget (column G) are both shown below. For the flexible budget, I used the same assumptions as the static budget but changed the volume to 110 units (compare cells F3 and G3). This pattern closely resembles the budgeting, costing, and variance analysis pattern followed by most modern firms of significant size. Management should only pay attention to those that are unusual or particularly significant. Often, by analyzing these variances, companies are able to use the information to identify a problem so that it can be fixed or simply to improve overall company performance. Unfortunately, a variance report can’t be finalized until the actual events occur.